angrybanette:
grim-dark:
your ~social justice~ pass has been hereby revoked.
omg are we still thinking that moffat is capable of writing queer chars and holmes and watson aren’t straighty mc straight straight?
some people cannot fucking do critical media analysis to save their…
Wait…Where does it say that Lucy Liu’s Joan Watson is queer? That is not the vibe the getting from the trailers.
Also, I’m not sure about the BBC’s John and Sherlock, but Arthur Conan Doyle’s Holmes and Watson are definitely not Straight McStraight Straight. Queer readings of canon are possible, even inevitable, since neither character follows a hetero-normative life script in an era when there was far more social pressure to do so.
I badly want to see a modern adaption of Sherlock Holmes that takes into account the implications of their relationship. I want it before Joan Watson’s character starts sending out baby shower invitations (don’t say it isn’t going to happen, look at Temperance Brennan and Dr. Dana Sculley).
I’d like a Queer Holmes and Watson in something more like 221B Baker Towers, but I’d also like BBC Sherlock to grow up and stop it with the fanservice and get to the real heart of this matter. I don’t put my hope in Moffat but I do put it in Mark Gatiss. Anyone want to dispute his credentials to write queer characters?
One more thing, because I’ve been one quietly steaming Queer Holmesian for awhile. I like Lucy Liu. She’s fierce and beautiful and awesome. I’d love her as Holmes. But she still doesn’t feel like a Watson to me. The trailers haven’t helped. It’s like seeing Mark Hamill in Harrison Ford’s costume.